Pages

January 30, 2012

No Good Deed


Angut Kiest, an unemployed Greenland-er, found himself in an interesting predicament.  In 2008, unable to find a job, he went to the bank in to close out his account and hope for the best.  What he found, instead, was a tempting  situation.  His account had been credited with approximately 180,000 euros – or as we like to say stateside, “A whole lotta cold, hard cash.”   (For those of you doing the conversion on your iPhones even as we speak, that’s almost a quarter of a million dollars.)

Instead of reporting the overage to the bank, Angut turned into an angel.  He gave some money to his family, also unemployed and hurting.  He gave some money to his friends, who found themselves to be in the down-and-out position as well.  He even took some excess cash to the supermarket and, instead of purchasing groceries for himself, he gave some money to the beggars who positioned themselves outside the store hoping for an extra can of something or an extra loaf of anything. 

Eventually, of course, the bank realized their mistake and froze his almost empty account.  They ordered Angut to pay back the money and pay it back now.  Angut stated that he thought the extra cash came from a German lottery winning (that he hadn’t entered - but that’s his story and he’s sticking to it!).  The bank told him he’d have to return or sell the items he purchased and pay back the money or they would prosecute him.

The trouble was this:  Angut didn’t have “things” to show for his withdrawls, unless you count the food for the hungry and the heat for the cold.  So, the bank took the modern-day Samaritan to court and the Danish high courts (which govern Greenland) ordered Angut, still unemployed, to pay the money back and to serve 100 hours of community service.

Angut insists he’s not a crook.  I believe him.  His intentions weren’t malicious.  He could have withdrawn the money and treated himself to a one-way ticket to Vegas and an endless stream of shows on the strip.  He could have snatched the cash and disappeared to the neighboring country of Iceland, which I hear is much, much nicer to look at than Greenland.  He could have done any number of things that would certainly land him with the title of Selfish Samaritan.  But he didn’t.  He chose to use the unaccounted for windfall to encourage others – even if through one meal.

I’m not advocating that when the banks make an error, we should all cash in and head out.  I am advocating for a little justice for Angut.  He was wrong – that’s not up for debate.  But, to ask the unemployed to pay back that which he doesn’t even have and is not capable of having is only digging his hole deeper.  Instead, maybe he could be sentenced to work in the government, and he can help determine appropriate ways to work with those less fortunate.  I think he’ll probably start with the actions he knows best:  generosity and kindness.

AddThis

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...